Thursday, November 5, 2015

Horse meat, round 1 (Updated!)

Something I've been wanting to do for many years is start incorporating the consumption of horse meat in my ritual feasts. The consumption of horse meat was a defining feature of Heathen religious practice for many years during the era of the conversion to Christianity, and the willingness to consume, or not consume, horse flesh was sometimes used as a test of one's faith...
The next day, when the people sat down to table, the bondes pressed the king strongly to eat of horse-flesh; and as he would on no account do so, they wanted him to drink of the soup; and as he would not do this, they insisted he should at least taste the gravy; and on his refusal they were going to lay hands on him.  Earl Sigurd came and made peace among them, by asking the king to hold his mouth over the handle of the kettle, upon which the fat smoke of the boiled horse-flesh had settled itself; and the king first laid a linen cloth over the handle, and then gaped over it, and returned to the high-seat; but neither party was satisfied with this. (Saga of Haakon the Good (Samuel Laing tr.), ch. 18)
The prohibition against eating horsemeat (and the explicitly Christian connotations) was enshrined into law...
If a man eats horse flesh he shall pay a fine of three marks to the bishop. ... If a man eats horse flesh in Lent, he shall forfeit all his property to the last penny and shall depart from the king's dominions. - Gulathing Law, the Church Law, 20
Now, horsemeat is a common enough ingredient in Europe and Canada, but is not found at all here in the U.S., mostly thanks to the animal rights lobby. It's not illegal to butcher horses for human consumption, but it's impossible for practical reasons, and although there's no direct ban on importing horse meat, there is a practical one, as the U.S. Customs and Border Protection service will not allow travelers to bring meat of any kind into the country.

I've tried several different exotic food websites in the U.S., but although one can get iguana, alpaca, and camel, horse is off the menu for some reason. And stores in Canada and Europe won't ship to the U.S., doubtless because of the aforementioned ban by U.S. customs.

However, I think that, given the fact that the the consumption of horse meat was a traditionally Heathen thing to do, and a blanket ban on all imported meat is hardly the least restrictive strategy for achieving the government's goal (which they'll doubtless say is public health), some sort of waiver for the importation of modest amounts of horse meat for religious purposes is not unreasonable.

So this is the email I sent to U.S. Customs and Border Protection:
Hello,
I am a practitioner of the Asatru religion, which is the reconstruction of the ancient faith of the Norse and Germanic peoples. An integral part of our religious faith centers around the consumption of horse meat during religious rituals, a practice that is well-attested in both the Icelandic Sagas and the Heimskringla (one of our historical religious texts). 
I lead an Asatru congregation in New Jersey, and we are looking for options to import a small amount of horse meat from Canada for our personal religious use. 
How do I go about requesting a religious exemption (under the authority of the First Amendment of the Constitution and the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act)? I would like some sort of letter that I can show to customs officials in order to be able to bring in a small amount of horse meat from Canada, again only for my personal religious use.
I would appreciate any information and assistance you could provide.
Sincerely,
Joseph Bloch, goði,
Skylands Asatru Fellowship
I'll report back when and if I get a reply (the website says to expect a wait of several weeks). This may end up in court!

UPDATE (11/5/2015): That was quick! I heard back from Customs, and they informed me that it's all right to bring in "personal consumption" quantities of horse meat from Canada. They pointed me to the USDA Animal Product Manual, which states, in Appendix A, page 33:
Personal-use amounts of equine meat or meat products commercially packaged and labeled will be allowed in passenger baggage. No import permit or other documentation is required.
So there we are! Problem solved. Now all I need is a passport.


8 comments:

  1. FYI - There is no "Christian" (Scriptural based) prohibition against the eating of horse flesh. You shouldn't confuse actions taken by the medieval Catholic Church as Biblical teachings.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm very sure I never said it was a Biblical teaching. However, there is a *lot* in Christianity, as practiced, that is not found in the Bible. That doesn't make it any less Christian. That said, I did point out that I was speaking about the period "during the era of the conversion to Christianity", and what I said was thus completely accurate.

      Delete
  2. My husband and I love eating horse meat. Horse steaks taste much better than beef, and it's healthier too. We butchered our horse meat in the back yard. We put two bullets right behind the horse's ear after letting it drink beer. Then we slit the throat and collect the blood. After it has bled out some, we remove the head so it can bleed out further and then we roll it on to a tarp for butchering. We don't have a gambrol strong enough to hang up a horse, so we use a clean tarp on a slight down hill angle so the carcass can finish draining. My husband skins it and does the rough butchering outside and then I do the finer butchering inside, including cutting roasts and steaks and grinding meat for ground meat and sausage. Start to finish, it takes about 12 to 16 hours, but we got enough meat to last a family of 4 a year and a half. The horse we killed was a blind mare who had been used as a brood mare for the last several years and was going to be sold to a dog food plant. My mother-in-law talked the owner into letting us have her for free. She went down real calm and easy and never saw it coming. Good luck!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You are a murderer. If you can kill and eat a helpless horse you have no soul. There is a reason this is illegal in most states

      Delete
    2. That made me hungry!
      Elk and bison are the best meat I've tasted thus far.
      Someone from Sweden told me horse meatballs are common, and also very tasty!

      Delete
  3. OMG, how gruesome. Horses are not "meat"

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You are factually incorrect. The designation of what is, and is not, an edible animal is determined by culture and religion. Horses are "meat" all over Europe and Canada. There's no reason they shouldn't be considered so here in the US as well, other than history. The government should not be in the business of enforcing personal preference.

      Delete
    2. I am not being literal ~sigh~ I well know that horse meat is common in Europe and other parts of the world I am simply saying they shouldn't be as they are by no means raised like typical "livestock". Besides the vast majority, if not all, horse meat in North America contains medications that are prohibited from entering the food chain (e.g. bute, clenbuterol etc.). Horse slaughter is an insidious, dirty business.

      Delete